Find our Pies in a Store Near You! Shop Now!

Your Cart (0)

View Cart
Purchase a minimum of 2 items to complete your order

close cart
Graham Cookie Crust
Cream Pies

Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping

32 oz
$44.50
Serves 6-8 People
Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping
Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping
Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping
Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping
Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping
Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping
Graham Cookie Crust
Cream Pies

Key Lime Pie + Free Shipping

32 oz
$44.50
Serves 6-8 People

Tangy fresh key west lime filling mixed with whole whipping cream and powdered sugar for a perfect mix of sweet and tart made on our fresh-baked graham cookie crumb crust.

  • SUPPORTING LOCAL FARMERS
    SUPPORTING LOCAL FARMERS
  • FARM FRESH CREAM
    FARM FRESH CREAM
  • THAW & SERVE
    THAW & SERVE
Why We’re Different
As good as grandma’s

Why We’re Different

ALWAYS
  • All natural ingredients
  • Farm-fresh locally sourced dairy
  • Scratch-made
  • Sustainably grown, no-till wheat
  • A whole lotta love!
NEVER
  • GMO ingredients
  • Artificial flavors or fillers
  • Artificial preservatives
  • High fructose corn syrup
  • Hydrogenated oils
Why We’re Different
  • Ingredients Info

    16 Simple Ingredients: Sweetened Condensed Milk (Whole Milk, Sugar), Key Lime Juice From Concentrate (Water, Key Lime Juice Concentrate, Lime Oil), Cream, Cage Free Egg Yolk, Wheat Flour, Palm Oil,  Graham Flour, Powdered Sugar (Sugar, Cornstarch), Sugar, Butter (Cream, Salt), Crystallized Lime (Citric Acid, Lime Oil, Lime Juice) Molasses, Honey, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Sodium Bicarbonate. 

    Contains: Wheat, Milk, Egg

  • Thawing Instructions

  • FAQs
    How long can I keep a fresh baked pie, or cream pie?

    For best quality, we recommend using our fruit pies within 3 days, if kept at room temperature. Thawed cream pies should be kept in refrigeration and eaten within 4 days.

    Can I bake a Ready to Bake Pie that is thawed in the refrigerator?

    Our Ready to Bake Pies are designed to bake from a frozen state. In order to get the best quality product, we recommend that you do not allow the pie to thaw before baking.

    Can I bake two pies at once?

    You can bake two pies at the same time. Simply preheat your oven to 400 degrees and bake for 10 minutes. After that, reduce the heat and follow the regular baking instructions as listed on the pie box. Since ovens may vary, you may want to take a peek at the product during the last 15-20 minutes of the baking process. You may want to cover the edges with foil if you notice they are getting too brown.


    Got more questions? Check out our full FAQ to see more or feel free to reach out to us anytime.

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Traditional Pumpkin Pie + Free Shipping

All Butter Crust
$44.50
Free Shipping

Cherry Crunch Pie + Free Shipping

Artisanal Almond Topping
$44.50
Free Shipping

Triple Chocolate Cream Pie + Free Shipping

Chocolate Cookie Crumb Crust
$44.50
Free Shipping

Customer Reviews

Based on 1 review
100%
(1)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
N
NWARTIST
Delicious

I was satisfied with the quality, and it was delicious.